Preview

History and Archives

Advanced search

The issues of the French archival science during the 20th century in the light of the theoretical heritage of V.N. Avtokratov

https://doi.org/10.28995/2658-6541-2024-6-2-107-128

Abstract

The article considers the possibilities of applying the general and specific theories of archive studies, created by V.N. Avtokratov, for analyzing the causes and ways of resolving the crisis in the archive studies in France. It shows the similarity of the crisis phenomena observations in the French archive studies made independently by V.N. Avtokratov and Ch. Kecskemeti, and substantiates the scientific significance of analyzing the causes of this crisis, which allows for the development of V.N. Avtokratov’s theoretical approach. The document boom of the second half of the 20th century posed a challenge to the entire archival science, but each archival school was to overcome it in a different way. A crisis that occurred in the French archive studies was caused by the departure from the principle of unity of the fund and manifested itself in the changes in the use of archival documents in France. The analysis of that crisis from the theoretical positions formulated by V.N. Avtokratov helped to demonstrate how a weak development of certain theoretical issues (the concept of a creator of a fond, the issues of intra-fund systematization, the notions of value and utility) affected the professional training of archivists and the archival activities in France in terms of acquisition and use, particularly in the field of fund management and the policy of creating archival finding aids. The strong and weak aspects of the French archival theory and practice are shown in the article, and recommendations for the professional training of archivists in Russia are formulated.

About the Author

V. B. Prozorova-Tomas
“Abylsen” ; Magazine “Herald of an Archivist” in Europe
France

Victoria B. Prozorova-Tomas, Cand. of Sci. (History), Abylsen group consultant, Head of mission



References

1. Avtokratov, V.N. (2001), Teoreticheskie problemy otechestvennogo arkhivovedeniy. [Theoretical issues of the Russian archival science], Moscow, Russia.

2. Avtokratov, V.N. (2001), “From the history of the formation of classification representations in archive studies during 19th – early 20th century”, in Avtokratov, V.N. Teoreticheskie problemy otechestvennogo arkhivovedeniya [Theoretical issues of Russian archival science], Moscow, Russia, pp. 299–312.

3. Prozorova, V.B. (2017), Arkhivy – natsional’noe dostoyanie Frantsii XVIII–XX vekov [Archives as a national heritage of France in the 18th – 20th centuries], Aleteya, Saint Petersburg, Russia.

4. Prozorova, V.B. (2015), “Charles Kecskeméti. The life of an archivist”, in Trudy IAI RGGU [Proceedings of the IAI RGGU], vol. 41, pp. 335–359.

5. Kecskeméti, Ch. (2000), « La problématique actuelle des archives », in Kecskeméti Ch., Suveregny disputed claims professional culture essays of archival policies, Brussels, Belgium.

6. Tikhonov, V.I. (2015), “Archival theory of V.N. Avtokratov. The analysis of the main provisions and approaches”, RSUH/RGGU Bulletin. Series “Records Management and Archive Studies. Computer Science. Data Protection and Information Security”, no. 1, pp. 9–28.

7. Sleptsova, A.A. (2020), “ ‘During their lifetime, every person inevitably and repeatedly faces a need to use various documents…’: on the publication of the book ‘History of documents in Russia. Personalities and fates’ (historical, legal and records management aspects)’, ed. by V.N. Egorov, Ul’yanovsk: Korporatsiya tekhnologicheskogo prodvizheniya, 2020, 376 p.”, History and Archives, no. 2, pp. 149–156.

8. Starostin, E.V. (1997), Teoreticheskie problemy otechestvennogo arkhivovedeniya [Foreign archival science. Issues of history, theory and methodology], Russkii mir, Moscow, Russia.

9. Khorhkordina, T.I. (2022), Istoriya arkhivov i arkhivnogo dela v Rossii [History of archives and archives administration in Russia], Moscow, Russia.


Review

For citations:


Prozorova-Tomas V.B. The issues of the French archival science during the 20th century in the light of the theoretical heritage of V.N. Avtokratov. History and Archives. 2024;6(2):107-128. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.28995/2658-6541-2024-6-2-107-128

Views: 192


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2658-6541 (Print)